Select Page
Ubuntu 14.04 LTS Complaints are Missing the Point

Ubuntu 14.04 LTS Complaints are Missing the Point

I certainly understand Scott Gilbertson’s complaints about Ubuntu 14.04 LTS missing out on lots of the goodies that are in the works for Ubuntu, but I just can’t get at all worked up about the “missing” bells and whistles of this workhorse of an operating system.

Canonical pushed out Ubuntu 14.04 last week. This release is the first Ubuntu Long Term Support release in two years and will be supported for the next five years.

It feels like, for Canonical at least, this Long Term Support release couldn’t have come at a worse time. The company is caught in a transitional phase as it moves from a desktop operating system to a platform that spans devices.

The problem for Canonical is that it’s only about 90 percent of the way to a platform-spanning OS, but it just so happens that the company’s schedule calls for a Long Term Support release now.

Long Term Support releases are typically more conservative and focus on stability and long-term maintenance rather than experimental or flashy new features. Things that are 90 percent done don’t make it into LTS releases. And, unfortunately for Canonical, most of its foundation-shaking changes to Ubuntu are currently only about 90 percent done and thus not part of this release.

The two biggest changes on the horizon are the Mir graphics stack and Unity 8, neither of which are part of 14.04.

via Ubuntu 14.04 review: Missing the boat on big changes | Scott Gilbertson at Ars Technica.

I think my lack of concern stems from the way I see the semiannual releases of Ubuntu as very different from the Long Term Support versions rolled out biennially.  The regular releases that come out every six months are for the competent Linux user who is interested in staying on top of the latest and greatest advancements in the OS.  But for someone like me, who is pretty good at getting non-Linux users to give Ubuntu a whirl, the LTS versions are wonderful.

When I help someone new to Linux get started with  Ubuntu I make a point to set them up with an LTS version.  I want them to have the option of at least a few years of stability without major changes to the the Desktop UI and packages I install for them.  This transitional time is akin to running an OS with the training wheels attached.  If the user adapts quickly and wants to change they can switch over to the more frequent releases, but if they just want to get stuff done, they are all set for three to five years without needing to adapt to changes in how they use their computer.

(more…)